Vegetarian
Journal Book Review
Issue one, 2002
JUDAISM
AND VEGETARIANISM
Reviewed by Matt Terl
Judaism and Vegetarianism is not a moderate
work. The first chapter opens with the assertion that
God's intention was that people be vegetarians, and
Schwartz maintains that tone for much of the book.
Beyond this attitude, however, which I initially found
somewhat off-putting, Schwartz has taken a challenging
subject and crafted an eminently readable analysis
of it.
Schwartz realizes the ways in which
Judaism and vegetarianism appear to be in direct conflictas
evidenced by traditional foods, Biblical sacrifices,
and so onand takes pains to account for each
of these contradictions. He ties a vegetarian lifestyle
into Judaic traditions such as charity, compassion
for life, and peace. His choices of sources are all
excellent, and he does not rely on bad translations
to do his work for him. His arguments are compelling
and well-written.
Schwartz devotes a full chapter to
a simple question-and-answer format that actually
takes into account a number of things about which
I had found myself curious while reading the book.
The questions address general aspects of vegetarianism,
such as "Is
vegetarianism an effective approach to weight loss?"
as well as questions more specifically related to
Judaism. However, the book is unlikely to appeal to
those for whom questions of Judaism and vegetarianism
are not of particular importance. While the vegetarian
arguments have a universality about them, there is
little there that cannot be found in greater detail
elsewhere.
On the other hand, if you have an interest
in Judaism, vegetarianism, and where the two intersect,
or you are a non-vegetarian Jew who is searching for
an understanding of where religion and an ethical
diet intersectperhaps having such a search forced
on you by a significant otherthis book is an
excellent resource.
Judaism and Vegetarianism (ISBN
1-930051-24-7) is published by Lantern Books. Reviewed
by Matt Terl, a graduate of the Charles E. Smith Jewish
Day School and the University of Maryland.